![]() |
| Arthur Rackham |
Part 1
As before, I’m letting things grow organically. No real order besides the order ideas come to me.
Housekeeping
Before I get started, three things..
#1: A few of my real-life friends said it’d be helpful to have a list of references, since they’re more familiar with Tolkien than the works I’m pulling for the experiment, so here’s the list for part 1:
- Middle Earth = Various (To be determined)
- The One Ring = Seal of Solomon (Testament of Solomon, etc.)
- Eru Illuvatar -MANA-YOOD-SUSHAI (The Gods of Pegana)
- The Valar = The Zoa (The prophetic works of William Blake)
- Mordor = The Land of Darkness (The Alexander Romance)
- The Nazgul = The 12 Paladins of Charlemagne (Orlando Furioso, etc)
- The Witch-King = Alexander the Above-Average (The Alexander Romance)
- Orcs = Tharks / Green Martians (A Princess of Mars + sequels)
- Sauron = Nyarlathotep (Cthulhu Mythos, various)
- Mount Doom = Mt. Elbrus (Real world + Zoroastrian mythology)
- Numenor = Atlantis (The Lost Continent, etc)
#2 is I learned about Tales Before Tolkien, which is a collection of 21 pre-Tolkien fantasy stories compiled by Douglas Anderson (did the annotated Hobbit, got to see him give a talk once, that was fun). Most if not all of those are PD; I haven’t properly dug through it yet, but I’m going to keep it as a nice backup resource for the future.
#3: Morgan Long pointed out in the comments to the Part 1 that I skipped over Der Ring des Nibelungen, and while my initial response had been “using Alberich’s ring itself is a bit on the nose and I just don’t care for the Cycle as a whole”, thinking about it more has opened up a very good path forward, and since I have no better segue let’s get into that.
Boromir
Siegfried / Sigurd, as portrayed in Der Ring des Nibelungen. My initial resistance fell off on further review, because he’s some of the rawest antagonist potential possible. The guy was raised in isolation as a human-shaped guided missile aimed towards a dragon’s hoard, and is easily read as a sociopath, and his parents were siblings, and he fucked his half-aunt and he’s a stooge of German nationalism. He’s the hero and he’s going to make it everyone else’s problem. Even if we're purely going on the first point and ignoring everything else, a human being raised to adulthood by an abusive parent with 0 other social contact is going to be absolutely fucked in the head.
What happens when the great golden manchild convinced that he's fated for age-defining greatness is put into a story that doesn't revolve around him? When the mask finally drops and the rest of the characters realize too late who they're working with, oh buddy that's where the drama lives. Chef's kiss.
- Q: How much of Der Ring can I offload to the background?
- Q: What happens after his betrayal of the fellowship?
- Q: How is his crusade to defeat Alexander going to backfire terribly after he steals the Seal?
- Addition: Mime the dwarf, Fafnir the dragon, a good number of the rest of the cast.
- Addition: The fortress of Valhalla and its king who started this entire mess by trying to get out of paying the contractors he hired to build it.
Treebeard
I had been combing Wikipedia for mythical and magical trees, but then remembered that ents in the books are tree-like but not necessarily trees themselves. So why not go with the OG forest guardian, Humbaba? (There is no reason why not)
- Q: So what else have Gilgamesh and Enkidu been doing? I suppose they didn’t kill Humbaba this time around - what sorts of injuries does he have?
- Q: Is he related in any way to the giants who built Valhalla?
- Addition: Cedars of Lebanon used in construction of Solomon’s Temple, which would provide some connection to the Seal.
Theoden
Hrothgar would be the obvious choice, but Hrothgar loses the horses and without horses it’s hardly Rohan. But! You know who has horses? Amazons. They also had a shit-ton of queens if we go by just the Greek sources, but Hippolyta is the main one and comes with some extremely fruitful potential expansions.
- Q: Is Hippolyta actually on the throne, or has the abduction-by-Theseus plot happened and Antiope or Penthesilea is ruling in her stead?
- Q: Speaking of which: what else has Theseus fucked up beyond all repair?
- Q: Well he did kill the Minotaur which means he now has a connection to Atlantis; how’d that turn out for him? Find any other treasures while looting the ruins?
- Addition: Herakles and/or Theseus, fucking around as usual.
- Addition: The Attic War
- Addition: Queen Calafia / any number of additional Amazonian monarchs
- Addition: Assorted cities / islands of women etc.
Eowyn
There’s no shortage of ladies in armor to choose from, but I think I’m going to go with Bradamante from the Orlando duology. It’s a bit of a double-dip since I’m sourcing the Nazgul from the same texts, but Bradamante has the bona fides to justify it:
- Accomplished knight on her own merit
- Equals-on-the-battlefield enemies-to-lovers plotline with the Andalusian warrior Ruggiero.
- Rescues Ruggiero from the evil wizard Atlantes by using a magic ring to break into his tower.
- Refuses to marry a man who can’t match her in combat (so as to counter her father’s attempt to marry her off to the prince of Byzantium)
- Sister of Rinaldo the paladin (and so would be related to one of the Nazgul in this version)
Pretty stacked resume. Absolute crime that she doesn't show up more often.
- Q: So how’d she end up as the foster daughter of the queen of the Amazons?
- Q: What’s her relationship with Rinaldo like?
- Q: So is Atlantes intentionally invoking a connection with Atlantis in his name? Like calling himself “the Atlantean” or something like that.
- Q: I guess his tower would probably be the equivalent of Isengard, then.
- Addition: Ruggiero, obviously
- Addition: Using the Seal to rescue Ruggiero from the Atlantes’ tower.
- Addition: Probably need a stand-in for Islam, now. Or at least a faction to stand in for Andalusia. Iram of the Pillars would be the obvious choice but I’m not making that call just yet.
Shadowfax
Rakhsh, steed of Rostam in the Shahnameh. If Rohan = Amazons and Amazons = Scythia, that's right next door. Rakhsh also has the “legendary horse who can only be ridden by a legendary hero” thing going on, though he also died alongside Rostam in the story. So either a surviving (and potentially wounded) Rakhsh, or a descendant. Either way, it should be a Big Deal when he chooses a rider.
- Q: Who does Rakhsh permit as his rider? One time deal, or no?
- Q: It’s probably going to be Bradamante, so what circumstances lead us to that point? Would it be the mission to rescue Ruggiero, or a later battle?
- Addition: Rostam & his seven feats, Zahhak, Div-e Sepid
- Addition: Indo-Scythian peoples (since that territory would overlap with Samangan and that's where Rostam's wife Tahmina is from, boom there’s a Rostam > Amazonia link.)
Fun fact: Rakhsh is Aramaic for “horse”, so he’s the horse named Horse.
Gollum
It’s gotta be Caliban: Classic fucked-up little dude who has connections to at least two powerful magic users and is part of a plot centered around imprisoned spirits. Easy pick.
- Q: How did he get the Seal? Inherited it from Sycorax? How'd she get it?
- Q: What else is on that island?
- Q: How does Prospero get entangled in all this?
- Addition: Ariel and the spirits of the island
- Addition: Sycorax, who is clearly not on good terms with the rest of the wizards
Tom Bombadil
An Elder Thing with old hippie professor energy. Could probably pull double duty as Dr. Doolittle (an Elder talking to humans is kinda like a human talking to animals, from their point of view) or Professor Challenger (banger name; also, I like the premise of Elders as Victorian gentleman-scientist-explorers)
Since Goldberry doesn’t have much to her beyond “some sort of river spirit”, we’ve got more nymphs, naiads, nixies, undines, rusalkas, and so, so many others to choose from. But Nimue / the Lady of the Lake has the most connective tissue to draw on and I’ve yet to find an alternative of similar caliber (though Jenny Greenteeth has “spooky monster with a fun name” covered.)
- Q: All right, who’s she throwing swords at this time?
- Q: Are we going to keep in the Lancelot connection?
- Q: What do people think about the Elder? What do they think he is?
- Q: Are there any other surviving Elders on the planet?
- Q: What’s his beef with the mi-go about?
- Q: Actually, wait, hold up; Wagner’s ring is made from gold stolen from the spirits of the Rhine, Goldberry-Nimue is our resident water-spirit, did the Seal get stolen from her in parallel? Would that imply that the Seal is an Elder Thing artifact? Or did it just fall into Nimue’s possession for a while?
- Addition: So about those shoggoths…
- Addition: Cambrian sea life, as a treat
Elrond
Elrond’s a problem child in this experiment: his primary role in the narrative could be fulfilled by any old wizard, but his primary relationship is bound up with Arwen, and Arwen is tied up with Aragorn, and I still don’t know what I want to do with Aragorn.
The three of them basically come as a package deal, and the two main packages that I know of are:
- Alveric, Lirazel, and the King of Elfland from Dunsany’s King of Elfland’s Daughter
- Pwyll, Rhiannon, and Arawn from the Mabinogion
I like the Pwyll triad better, but it’s also definitely a major direct inspiration of Tolkien’s, which I have generally been trying to avoid. So I’d either need to tie in some wildcards or learn to suck it up and deal. I mean I already used Der Ring the glass on that box has been broken.
I’ll come back to this, see what I can do with it later. How elves are actually going to be situated is still very much in-progress.
Galadriel
The Lady von Willendorf herself, a pick that will not surprise regular readers of the blog but may require a hear me out for folks just wandering by, so hear me out:
Galadriel is extremely powerful, extremely beautiful, and extremely old. And while there are plenty of powerful + beautiful + ancient women in myth and literature to choose from, I don’t think many of them can brag about being an instantly-recognizable sex icon 20,000+ years after their creation. This also throws a fun wrench into the genre by portraying one of the OG ur-elves that everyone ripped off afterward as short, brown and fat instead of tall, pale and thin, while still presenting her with the dignity and respect that she’s owed.
As a bonus, the Venus gives us an entirely different direction to approach elven melancholy: Galadriel’s depressed because she remembers when there used to be mammoths, and now the mammoths have gone and they will never return.
- Q: Is she actually an elf in this anymore, or an immortal human living among the elves?
- Addition: Okay well now I gotta have one last mammoth show up. There will be waterworks.
- Addition: Of course the mammoth remembers her, whose blog do you think you're reading? Man might forget, but the elephants do not.
- Addition: And you’d best believe she was one of the painters of Lascaux. Like her house is just built on top of or right beside the entrance.
And, having said all that, I could very easily invoke many of the elements I used for the Great Lady for the "instead of a dark lord you would have a queen" bit. Works out nice, especially since Nyarlathotep = Sauron. Never met a good idea I wouldn't use twice.
Bilbo Baggins
Nathaniel Chanticleer from Hope Mirrlees' Lud-in-the-Mist. Fantasy-English small-town burgher whose life is normal and regular and entirely un-adventurous up until magical adventure barrels into his life and turns it upside down.
- Addition: Fairy-fruit and its importation into the human world
Gimli and Legolas
Conan and Zorro, no contest. Got the heavy fighter and the finesse fighter, got the opposed personalities primed for a mild antagonism > grudging respect > unbreakable friendship storyline. Howard’s Picts are basically Frazetta-style cavemen, you already know I’m going to use neanderthals as dwarves, the numbers check out.
Bonus: since they both have terrible vulture estates who love suing over trademarks, both of them need makeovers and new names. Conan’s easy, already did him: Spakāya of Cimmeria, or we can just call him “The Hound”. Zorro is “fox” in Spanish, which is “Rusc” in Sindarin (fun fact: only materials about conlangs fall under copyright, since you can’t copyright a language) and while Fox and the Hound isn’t public domain, it is a funny little reference.
(Note: Zorro was actually a suggestion from skullelongator on bluesky, who got it from their mother. Thanks, skullelongator’s mom.)
- Addition: Side characters, etc. Leaving this part open, since the advantage of long-running picaresque pulp heroes is that you can drop them in just about anywhere without worrying about connections.
Barad-dûr
The Tower of Babel is the perfect fit, especially if I weave in its historical inspiration, Etemenanki. Its name is literally “Temple of the Foundation of Heaven and Earth”, it’s located at the seat of imperial power, it’s dedicated to the usurping god of kingship who built the world out of a corpse, historical Alexander the Great ordered it rebuilt. Throw in the “everyone spoke one language” with an implied “by force” and you’ve got the axis mundi of mythic oppression.
- Q: Can I resist the urge to go “invading the heavens wasn’t an exaggeration, they built a fucking space elevator”?
- A: No, probably not.
- Q: Can I resist the urge to go “and it was built on top of Çatalhöyük because I know authors who use subtext and they are all cowards? (Mysteryspice suggested this)
- A: Again, probably not.
- Q: Alexander’s obviously using it as a base of operations - why?
- Q: What connection, if any, between the Tower and Atlantis?
- Addition: Marduk, Tiamat, the Enuma Elish etc
- Addition: Oh hey Gilgamesh, how’s it hanging, man?
- Addition: The confusion of tongues (yay linguistic diversity)
The Council of the Wise
There’s a passage in Fellowship where Gandalf describes Saruman as “...great among the Wise [...] chief of my order and the head of the Council.” and that really makes it sound like there are more than five of them. Certainly more than two. I still don’t have a true pick for Gandalf yet, but the shortlist for the wizards’ council includes:
- Archimago (The Faerie Queene)
- Atlantes (Orlando Innamorato)
- Prospero (The Tempest)
- Medea (Medea, Argonautica, etc)
- Circe (The Odyssey, etc)
- Merlin (Arthuriana)
- Morgan le Fay (Arthuriana)
- Väinämöinen (Kalevala)
- Oannes (Sumerian myth)
- Gorice XII (The Worm Ouroboros)
- Oscar Diggs (The Wonderful Wizard of Oz)
Could probably throw in Hermes Trismegistus if I wanted to, but keeping him as fictional in-universe appeals to me, especially if I’m rolling with a layer of obfuscation about the Seal. Or he could be the wildcard that everyone in-universe thinks is fictional.
- Q: So how do these wizards interact with the rest of the world?
- Q: Who has beef with who?
- Q: What do they know of / care about the Seal? Have they done anything about it?
- Q: Has the Gandalf stand-in gone rogue?
- Q: Where do they meet?
- Q: How did the Wizard of Oz get invited, anyway?
- Addition: Lairs, drama, etc.
**
And that’s a wrap on Part 2. This experiment continues to be extremely fun, I've already got some ideas cooking already for Part 3, stay tuned.


